Have you heard about the latest parenting kerfuffle that has everyone talking?

Jenna Lyons, President of J.Crew, was last month photographed painting her 5 year-old child’s toenails fluro pink for a promotion by the retailer. All sounds pretty harmless, right? Well it would be if her child wasn’t a boy.

Unwittingly, Lyons and her son opened a Pandora’s Box of gender stereotypes. Protests came loudly and swiftly. Fox News called the ad, ‘blatant propaganda celebrating transgendered confusion’ while from groups like One Million Moms urged followers to write protest letters to J Crew stating, ‘to carry our nontraditional activities with a boy …can be destructive and damaging to a child’s identity and and self-esteem.’

……….

 

It’s an unfortunate cutural reality that our stereotypes for boys are more narrow and inflexible than for girls. A girl who likes to play with trucks or try football is seen has having a bit of spunk. Whereas a boy who wants to take dance classes or aspires to be a nurse is seen as a sissy boy or gender confused.

Dr William Pollack, a professor in the Psychiatry Department at Harvard University, has spent nearly two decades doing clinical research on boys and what he calls, “the crisis in boyhood in America today.”

“If a boy wants to dress up now and then in his mother’s clothes, what he’s doing is identifying with one of the most loved people in his life – he is not dis-identifying with being a boy,” says Pollack.

……….

 

The other night, our two year old stood on a step and watched me do my makeup. When I had finished, he rummaged around a drawer, produced my blush and asked that I put it on him. He also likes to occassionaly stack as many of my bangles up his arm as possible. And somedays when we got to playgroup he prefers to push a dolly around in a stroller rather than push the toy lawnmower.

Does this make him any less of a boy? Does it make me concerned? Absolutely not.

The greatest gift I can give Alfie is the opportunity to explore, learn and just ‘have a crack’ at new things. I want him to grow into an interesting person, and the only way that will happen is by giving him the freedom to try things out regardless of whether they fall into pink or blue stereotypes.

While are all too happy to champion equal rights for both sexes, it seems retrograde to that we take such a rigid view of our boys and masculinity.

Over to you – Does this ad bother you? How do you see your children explore gender?

 

Ps: I’ve been nominated as a Kidspot Top 50 Blogger. I’d be tickled pink if you took a moment to vote for me!

 

Image: Signature9
  1. Yulia

    I totally agree with you! Pink, blue, purple, green…whatever! My 2yr old went to a toyshop recently and all she wanted was a truck and together with that some cars…she was with my parents. They bought it for her but then I got an earful….”you know she does not wear enough dresses you ‘should’ really make sure she does not wear pants all the time…these days you need to ensure that you make her more of a girl if you know what I mean…can you believe she wanted a truck instead of a dolly!” Yep….for real, that’s what they told me! I pushed the comment right back with a laugh!!! Of course my parents replied with….’it’s not funny…we are serious!”

  2. I’ve got two boys, and have bought them a Barbie, a tea set etc in a bid to not close their minds to gender stereotyping. Barbie just gets called “Boobie girl”, but sometimes they will “pour me a mean cup of tea”.
    When I paint my nails, sometimes they want theirs painted too. Just blue though…

  3. This ad does not bother me at all! People from different tribes and cultures decorate their bodies in all sorts of different ways irrespective of gender. Its just called “having fun” and expressing yourself. Really – people that criticize things like this have the issues…

  4. I love this ad and I’m not at all bothered by it. I have a 2 year old son and ATM his favourite colour is -” PINK ” (We have to get PINK donuts – PINK crayons – PINK stickers) It doesn’t worry me the slightest and l certainly dont lose sleep at night worring that he MAY have ” gender issues” This summer just gone l was out in our yard painting my toe nails “PINK” and he asked for some too – I didnt think twice and painted them for him which he was absolutley delighted by. On the flip side he loves mud – trucks and motorbikes. l think people are to quick to jump on ‘gender issues’ these days – let kids be KIDS and if they want to try MUMS pink nail polish let them – no harm ever came from it.

  5. That’s funny, I didn’t even think twice about a little boy having his nails painted until I read further. He’s a kid! Who cares? I used to go topless when I was that age…I’m not slutty or ‘gender confused’ tpday.

ADD YOUR COMMENT

YOUR NAME

Required Field

EMAIL ADDRESS (Will not be published)

Required Field

WEBSITE ADDRESS

YOUR COMMENT